Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Jay's avatar

Hi Patrick, this is my first time visiting your substack site, but I have been a listener to your podcast since the Rome days. I enjoyed Roman and Early Modern series. I was a very wary of your announcement to move the current Neolithic time frame. However your manner of communication have warmed me up to the topic over the last few months and introduced me to a whole new world. Keep up the good work.

Expand full comment
Rowan's avatar

I notice you write (essentially) "Even though agriculture involved poorer nutrition etc., people were able to have more children more rapidly." That implies a difference in fertility rates specifically. A) am I understanding that right, and b) is there any speculation or evidence that agricultural packages supported higher fertility? Like maybe the nutrition, even if it was bad in some ways, was good at supporting more frequent pregnancies. Maybe the type of work allowed more frequent pregnancies, or new cultural practices forced it. Maybe it's that more children survived to adulthood for some reason, even if that adulthood was stressful and precarious.

I am LOVING the prehistory series. It's all just totally new to me. I'm glad you're talking about social structures and state or pre-state structures whenever you're able, because I'm trying to get through Fukuyama's "The Origin of Political Order" and so far it's really light on history ... I deeply want some facts to either buttress or challenge what I'm reading. I also want him to define his terms better. The practice you've had structuring narrative makes your work much more accessible and credible.

Expand full comment
14 more comments...

No posts